top of page

Rethinking the Farm Safety Net: What It Does, Who Benefits, and What Comes Next

11 minutes ago
6 min read

The Barry Flinchbaugh Center and Farm Foundation co-hosted Rethinking the Farm Safety Net on November 17, 2026, in Washington, D.C. Below are Farm Foundation’s key takeaways from the discussion. 


Four leading agricultural economists took on a hard question at our Washington, D.C., Forum: is today’s farm safety net built for the risks farmers actually face? 


When a drought, a trade dispute or a price collapse hits agriculture, what keeps the farm economy standing? 


For nearly a century, the answer has been some version of the farm safety net. But that net looks very different today than it did even ten years ago. That was the starting point for our November 17, 2026 Farm Foundation Forum, Rethinking the Farm Safety Net, held in Washington, D.C., and online. We co-hosted the conversation with the Barry Flinchbaugh Center for Ag and Food Policy. Thank you to ArentFox Schiff for hosting us and to Farm Credit for its ongoing support of the Forums. 


Watch the Full Discussion



New to the farm bill? Start here 


What it is. The farm bill is a package of federal laws that Congress typically renews about every five years. Despite the name, it reaches far beyond farms. It covers crop insurance and farm support programs, conservation, nutrition assistance (mainly SNAP, which makes up the large majority of farm bill spending), trade promotion, farm credit, rural development, agricultural research and more. The last full farm bill passed in 2018. Since then, Congress has extended its programs and, in 2025, used a budget reconciliation law to update much of the farm safety net. 


What the “farm safety net” means. It’s the set of programs that help farmers stay in business when weather or markets turn against them. It has three main parts: 

  • Crop insurance: farmers buy policies, with federal premium support, that protect against yield or revenue losses. 

  • Commodity programs (often called Title I, including ARC and PLC): payments that kick in when prices or revenues for major crops fall below set levels. 

  • Disaster and ad hoc assistance: aid Congress or USDA approves after a specific crisis, like a drought, a trade dispute or a pandemic. 


Why it matters, even if you don’t farm. These programs shape what gets grown and where, what farmland costs and rents for, how lenders decide what to lend, and how rural communities fare. If you’re starting a farm, renting land, working in ag lending or agribusiness, or building a career in food and agriculture policy, the farm bill is part of your working environment. 


A conversation in Barry’s spirit 

Dr. Barry Flinchbaugh‘s relationship with Farm Foundation began with a grant in 1968. He went on to become a Round Table Fellow, a board member and eventually board chair. Over nearly 50 years at Kansas State University, he taught agricultural policy to more than 4,000 undergraduates, had a hand in every farm bill from 1968 on, and advised leaders from both parties. 


“If you ever interviewed Barry, you know you didn’t just get a quote, you got an education,” said Dana Woodbury, executive director of the Flinchbaugh Center. 


The Center carries forward his approach to policy education in four steps. Frame the issue without bias. Lay out a range of alternatives. Weigh the trade-offs: who gains, who pays and what might go wrong. Then leave the decision to policymakers, leaders and citizens. That’s how the morning ran. 


Takeaway 1: The safety net has three legs, and ad hoc aid has become one of the biggest 

Moderator Brad Lubben of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln traced how farm policy evolved. It started with price supports and supply controls in 1933, shifted to income support with the 1973 Farm Bill, and has moved steadily toward risk management. Today’s safety net rests on three legs: crop insurance, commodity programs and emergency or ad hoc assistance. 


That third leg has grown fast. Henrique Monaco of the University of Minnesota walked through decades of crop returns and found that the safety net has historically covered most losses in bad years and added to profits in good ones. Over roughly the past decade, he noted, about half of the support for crop producers came through ad hoc payments. His question to the room: if crop insurance and commodity programs are in place and working, why so much ad hoc aid? 


Takeaway 2: The goal is stability, not just income 

Jennifer Ifft, who holds the Flinchbaugh Agricultural Policy Chair at Kansas State University, pointed to the word that shows up again and again in the law: stability. In plain English, when markets or weather throw something at agriculture, the farm economy keeps going. That includes farm families, lenders and agribusinesses. 


Crop insurance, she argued, quietly transformed agricultural lending. Lenders can see a farm’s revenue floor and lend against it. Her research also suggests insured farms invest more in productivity-improving equipment. But she also called the current system fragile: each dollar of support seems to go less far than it used to. 


Takeaway 3: Who benefits isn’t as simple as it looks 

Many farmers will tell you they don’t keep their payments. The money goes to rent, inputs and the operating line. Ifft said the research backs that up: published estimates suggest 20 to 40 percent of farm support ends up with landowners through cash rents and land values. Some also flows to input suppliers. That’s basic economics: when support raises demand for something scarce, its price goes up. 


Robert L. Thompson, professor emeritus of agricultural policy at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, put it bluntly: no sector benefits from overpaying for its main capital asset. He added that payments tied to production do little for beginning or low-income farmers. If helping them is the goal, policy needs tools built for them. 


Takeaway 4: Tougher questions are coming 

Thompson urged the room to prepare for budget pressure. Federal debt and interest costs are rising, and he expects every part of the federal budget to face scrutiny, much as it did in the mid-1980s. He listed the questions he expects farm programs to face: 

  • Why do six crops receive 94 percent of farm program support? 

  • How do we justify paying the same farmer for the same loss through more than one program? 

  • Should the safety net cover shallow losses, or should farmers carry some risk themselves? 

  • “Are these farm support programs safety nets or are they hammocks?” 


Takeaway 5: Farm policy is bigger than the farm bill 

Several of the biggest forces shaping farm income sit outside the safety net entirely. Thompson noted that exports account for roughly 23 percent of U.S. farm sales revenue, and argued that trade policy matters at least as much as farm programs. He also pointed out that Brazil, China and India now each invest more in agricultural research than the United States. On top of that, he expects water scarcity and a more selective role for biofuels to reshape where and what American farmers grow. 


Rural communities came up too. Ifft observed that the U.S. doesn’t seem to have a rural policy the way it has a farm policy. Lubben noted that issues like broadband are often handled in separate legislation. 


Ideas on the table 

The panel didn’t pick a winner. That was the point. But several options surfaced: 

  • One tool per goal. Thompson cited a core economic principle: give each policy one objective and design it for that objective. 

  • Focus insurance subsidies on catastrophic losses and coordinate programs around a farm’s net losses (Thompson). 

  • Better align commodity programs with crop insurance, so support kicks in when low prices shrink insurance guarantees, reducing overlap and possibly the need for ad hoc aid (Ifft and Monaco). 

  • Farmer savings accounts. Canada already uses them. Ifft described a version that works like a health savings account, possibly with a government contribution, and called it one of the more innovative ideas she’s heard. 

  • More transparency about the total support individual operations receive across all programs (Thompson). 

  • A new commission modeled on the 21st Century Commission on Production Agriculture that Barry Flinchbaugh chaired, to take the long view (Thompson). 


From the Q&A 

The audience in the room and online pushed the conversation further: 

  • Is the farm-food coalition holding? With farm support and nutrition programs handled separately in last year’s budget reconciliation law, panelists weighed what comes next. Ifft noted the system tends to perpetuate itself: “Crop insurance is permanent, ad hoc is starting to feel permanent.” 

  • Are we covering the right risks? A question about a new ad hoc program for diesel costs sparked a lively exchange. “If you want to give economists heartburn, talk about a safety net for input costs,” Ifft said. Monaco added that input costs are partly within a farmer’s control, which makes them hard to insure. 

  • Should disaster aid go regional? Asked about state block grants for disaster response, Ifft said regional differences in how farmers prefer to manage risk are a real barrier to reform, though she’s wary of more regionalization. 

  • The lightning round: Will a new farm bill pass before January 3? The panel’s answer was a quick, unanimous no. 


Keep the conversation going 

  • Watch the full Forum

  • Share your views: Take the Farm Safety Net Preferences Survey by Friday Nov 20th.

  • Join us December 11 in Washington, D.C., or online. We’re turning the usual year-end outlook on its head: two agricultural economists and a food scientist will each make three predictions for 2027, and you’ll help test them. Forums are free and open to everyone.


     

Speakers 

  • Moderator: Brad Lubben, Extension Associate Professor, Policy Specialist, and Director of the North Central Extension Risk Management Education Center, Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Nebraska–Lincoln 

  • Jennifer Ifft, Professor & Flinchbaugh Agricultural Policy Chair, Kansas State University 

  • Henrique Monaco, Assistant Professor, Applied Economics, University of Minnesota 

  • Robert L. Thompson, Professor Emeritus of Agricultural Policy, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page